NHTSA Safety Ratings Explained: How to Read Crash Test Results
When shopping for a vehicle, safety should be a top priority. NHTSA's 5-Star Safety Ratings help you compare crash test results and make informed decisions. This guide explains how these ratings work and what they mean for you and your family.
What is NHTSA?
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) is a federal agency within the U.S. Department of Transportation. Their mission is to save lives, prevent injuries, and reduce vehicle-related crashes. One of their key programs is the New Car Assessment Program (NCAP), which has been crash testing vehicles since 1978.
NHTSA's ratings are completely independent—manufacturers don't pay for testing, and the results are based solely on objective crash test data. This makes them one of the most trusted sources for vehicle safety information.
Understanding the 5-Star Rating System
NHTSA uses a simple 1-5 star scale to rate vehicle safety:
Important: These ratings compare vehicles within the same weight class. A 5-star compact car isn't necessarily safer than a 4-star SUV in a real-world collision, because the SUV is larger and heavier.
Three Types of Crash Tests
NHTSA conducts three main types of crash tests, each examining different collision scenarios:
1. Frontal Crash Test
What it tests: A vehicle crashes head-on into a fixed barrier at 35 mph, simulating a collision where the front of the vehicle absorbs the impact.
What it measures:
- Driver and front passenger injury risk
- Head, chest, and leg protection
- Airbag performance
- Structural integrity
Why it matters: Frontal crashes account for approximately 52% of serious car accidents. A high frontal crash rating means better protection in the most common type of severe collision.
2. Side Crash Test
What it tests: A moving barrier (simulating another vehicle) crashes into the driver's side of the vehicle at 38.5 mph and a pole crashes into the driver's side at 20 mph.
What it measures:
- Protection for front and rear seat occupants
- Side airbag and curtain airbag effectiveness
- Door structure integrity
- Head, chest, and pelvis injury risk
Why it matters: Side impacts are particularly dangerous because there's less vehicle structure between you and the other car. Side airbags and strong door beams are critical.
3. Rollover Resistance
What it tests: Not a crash test, but a calculation based on the vehicle's center of gravity and track width. Vehicles are also subjected to a "fishhook" maneuver at high speed.
What it measures:
- Likelihood of rollover in a single-vehicle crash
- Roof strength (if rollover occurs)
- Electronic stability control effectiveness
Why it matters: Rollovers are particularly deadly. Taller vehicles (SUVs, trucks) have higher centers of gravity and are more prone to rollover, but modern stability control systems have dramatically reduced rollover crashes.
How NHTSA Determines Star Ratings
Each crash test uses sophisticated crash test dummies equipped with dozens of sensors that measure forces on different body parts. Here's how the process works:
- Crash test conducted: Vehicle undergoes multiple collision scenarios
- Data collected: Sensors measure impact forces on head, neck, chest, legs, pelvis
- Injury risk calculated: Data converted into probability of serious injury
- Stars assigned: Based on injury probability thresholds
Overall Safety Score
In addition to individual test ratings, NHTSA provides an Overall Safety Score (1-5 stars). This combines all test results into a single rating using this formula:
- Frontal Crash: 40% of overall score
- Side Crash: 30% of overall score
- Rollover: 30% of overall score
While the overall score is useful for quick comparisons, it's important to look at individual test scores too. A vehicle could have a high overall rating but poor performance in one specific area that matters to you.
Advanced Safety Features
Beyond crash test ratings, NHTSA also tracks the availability of advanced safety technologies:
Electronic Stability Control (ESC)
Required since 2012. Helps prevent skidding and loss of control by automatically applying brakes to individual wheels. Reduces fatal single-vehicle crashes by approximately 50%.
Forward Collision Warning (FCW)
Alerts you when you're approaching another vehicle too quickly. Studies show it reduces rear-end crashes by 27%.
Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB)
Automatically applies brakes if you don't respond to collision warning. Can prevent crashes entirely or reduce impact severity. Reduces rear-end crashes by 50%.
Lane Departure Warning (LDW) and Lane Keep Assist (LKA)
Warns you (LDW) or actively steers (LKA) if you drift out of your lane. Particularly helpful for preventing highway single-vehicle crashes.
Blind Spot Detection
Warns you when another vehicle is in your blind spot. Reduces lane-change crashes by 14%.
Backup Camera
Required since 2018. Shows the area behind your vehicle when reversing. Dramatically reduces backover accidents, especially involving children.
How to Use Safety Ratings When Shopping
Step 1: Check Your VIN
Use our free VIN decoder to verify the exact vehicle specifications, including safety features. The same model can have different features depending on trim level.
Step 2: Look Up Safety Ratings
Visit NHTSA's SaferCar website or check ratings in our VIN decoder results. Look for:
- Overall rating (aim for 4-5 stars)
- Individual test scores
- Advanced safety feature availability
Step 3: Compare Similar Vehicles
Don't just look at one vehicle in isolation. Compare ratings across all vehicles you're considering in the same class.
Step 4: Consider Your Priorities
- Families with children: Prioritize side crash and rollover ratings
- Long commuters: Forward collision warning and AEB are crucial
- New drivers: Look for full suite of driver assistance features
- Highway drivers: Lane keep assist and blind spot monitoring matter most
Limitations of NHTSA Ratings
While extremely valuable, NHTSA ratings have some limitations to understand:
Not All Vehicles Are Tested
NHTSA can only test a limited number of vehicles each year. Low-volume vehicles or older models may not have ratings. No rating doesn't mean unsafe—it means untested.
Tests Don't Cover Every Scenario
Real-world crashes involve infinite variables. NHTSA tests common scenarios but can't test everything. Ratings are best-effort predictions, not guarantees.
Weight Class Matters
Remember: ratings compare vehicles within similar weight classes. In a collision between two vehicles of different sizes, the larger, heavier vehicle typically provides better protection for its occupants.
Ratings Can Change Year to Year
A vehicle redesign can significantly affect safety ratings. Always check the rating for the specific model year you're considering.
NHTSA vs. IIHS Ratings
You may also see ratings from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). While both are reputable, they use different methodologies:
Best approach: Check both if available. A vehicle that scores well with both organizations is an excellent safety choice.
Real-World Safety Beyond Ratings
While ratings are important, real-world safety depends on multiple factors:
Driver Behavior
The safest car in the world can't protect you if you're distracted, speeding, or driving impaired. Safe driving habits are more important than any rating.
Vehicle Maintenance
Worn tires, faulty brakes, or malfunctioning safety systems compromise protection. Regular maintenance is essential for safety.
Proper Use of Safety Features
- Always wear seatbelts (front AND back seats)
- Install child seats correctly
- Don't disable safety features
- Keep airbag areas clear
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can a 3-star vehicle be safe enough?
A: Three stars represents "average" protection. While not ideal, millions of people drive 3-star vehicles safely every day. However, if you can afford a 4 or 5-star vehicle, the extra protection is worth it, especially for families.
Q: Do older vehicles have safety ratings?
A: NHTSA has been testing since 1978, but testing standards have evolved. Ratings from before 2011 used different methodology and aren't directly comparable to modern ratings.
Q: Are bigger vehicles always safer?
A: Generally, yes—in a collision, occupants of larger, heavier vehicles fare better. However, larger vehicles may have higher rollover risk. The safest choice is a vehicle with good ratings in its size class that meets your needs.
Q: What if my vehicle has a recall?
A: Check for recalls using your VIN on NHTSA's website or our VIN decoder. If your vehicle has an open recall, get it fixed immediately—it's usually free, and it could save your life.
Check Your Vehicle's Safety Features
Decode your VIN to see exactly what safety features your vehicle has
Decode VIN Now →